Alexandria French

​

Film has an incredibly unique ability to explore the depths of human experience, turning abstract philosophical questions into vivid emotional narratives. This paper focuses on “Vagabond” by Agnes Varda and “Persona” by Ingmar Bergman, two films that do more than tell stories – they challenge us to think deeply about what it means to be ourselves.

​

The focus of this analysis is: In what ways do "Vagabond" and "Persona" blur the boundary between artistic expression and actuality as they investigate individual identity?

 

This investigation contextualizes these movies within philosophical frameworks that examine self-identity, and our existence in reality. The core argument highlights how specific cinematic techniques utilized by both films add not only to theoretical conversations concerning one's sense of self but also show us issues surrounding recollections, personal characteristics, and being alive resulting in a deeper comprehension of human nature.

Challenging the viewer's perceptions of identity and existence, both films employ unique narrative and visual styles. "Vagabond" delves into societal marginalization as well as individual autonomy in a raw, unfiltered manner while "Persona" explores fluidity and duality within identities through its intricate storytelling structure. The objective of this study is to analyze how cinema reflects reality whilst shaping our understanding of it; it pushes boundaries for self-actualization philosophically & practically alike by studying these movies.

 

 

 

Section 1: Conceptual Framework

​

Investigating the Philosophical Notions of Self-Awareness

The philosophical investigation of selfhood revolves around the fundamental nature of being human, with a particular emphasis on individual experience and existence within contextual frameworks. This inquiry draws from existential and phenomenological traditions that explore the dynamics shaping personal identity. Existential philosophy, exemplified by luminary thinkers such as Jean-Paul Sartre and Martin Heidegger, suggests that actions constitute an individual's essence rather than innate qualities predetermined at birth since they assert existence preceding it. Phenomenology encompasses work pioneered by Edmund Husserl coupled with later contributions made by Maurice Merleau-Ponty to focus attention on how lived experiences shape perception about surroundings while guiding engagement in daily life activities for individuals.

Rejecting the notion of a disassociated and neutral observer, both existentialism and phenomenology emphasize that comprehension is achieved through active involvement with our surroundings. This standpoint proves integral to investigating how individuals shape their sense of self via interpersonal interactions. Such philosophical foundations furnish an insightful lens for scrutinizing films such as "Vagabond" and "Persona," which explore intricacies relating to personal identity and societal expectations.

​

The Role of Art in Reflecting and Evaluating Reality.

Art functions as a societal mirror by presenting human existence and scrutinizing its intricacies. In the film, this is done through both visual storytelling and narrative techniques that convey psychological and philosophical complexities effectively. Films are not just replicas; they involve viewers in an active discourse that solicits them to reexamine their outlook on reality.

The correlation connecting film and the viewer is reminiscent of the notion of intentionality in phenomenology, which proposes that consciousness is invariably aware of something, and significance arises through its relationship to cognitive objects. As a result, art transcends just representing images by engaging spectators in an active process of creating meaning rather than just being passive recipients.

​

The use of cinematic techniques as a means to further explore philosophical concepts

Filmmaking techniques, including framing, pacing, and sound design are fundamental in influencing how viewers perceive characters. Such methods have the power to divide characters apart or blend scenes together to disrupt conventional beliefs about identity and truth. Close-up shots can expose internal struggles while disjointed narratives might mirror our fragmented understanding of memory and self-image.

The utilization of black and white rather than color, the interplay between light and shadow, along with time manipulation through editing have the ability to accentuate crucial existential concepts such as isolation, freedom, and alienation. These cinematic techniques aren't just for superficial visual appeal but act as an aid in deepening philosophical investigations into perceptions of being alive.

 

Methodology: Section 2

​

Utilizing an Analytical Perspective for the Evaluation of Movies

In this paper, an intricate inquiry is conducted on how movies shape and mirror actual perspectives of self-identity. The examination delves beyond mere interpretation by critically investigating the interplay between film as a medium and philosophical concepts encompassing being and presence. A qualitative approach based on meticulous scrutiny of cinematic instruments such as dialogue, cinematography, and editing techniques serves to uncover deeper insights in pursuit of thematic exploration concerning matters related to selfhood.

This study opts to use films as the primary source material due to their vast potential in dissecting intricate philosophical inquiries. Such medium is rich and multifaceted, providing an avenue through which complex issues may be thoroughly examined. More specifically, movies offer a potent tool for scrutinizing how individual identity interacts with societal norms - they allow simultaneous reflection of cultural contexts while influencing personal perspectives on such matters.

​

Film Selection Criteria

The movies "Vagabond" and "Persona" were chosen due to their deliberate exploration of self-identity themes, as well as their acclaimed implementation of inventive visual methods that provoke audiences' assessments regarding authenticity and veracity. These two motion pictures are recognized for their significant contribution to the European art cinema genre, praised for exhibiting profoundness in addition to reflecting meticulous craftsmanship from the directors focusing on both mental & individualistic elements inherent in each character's existence.

The movie "Vagabond" was selected for its raw depiction of social detachment and the examination of self-governance within societal norms. Agnes Varda effectively blends documentary-style storytelling with fictional components, resulting in a captivating exchange between the protagonist's perspective and what is conveyed to viewers objectively.

Ingmar Bergman's movie, "Persona," deeply explores the themes of identity and duality. With its symbolic and self-referential style, it challenges the traditional concepts that distinguish an individual from others. The film adopts a unique narrative approach where characters' personalities intertwine to create new identities or split into different personas entirely; this adds weight to its already-exemplary toolset for examining how our sense of self morphs due to both external relations with other people as well as internal emotional conflicts.

In addition to their content, the films will undergo scrutiny regarding how their form complements selfhood themes. The investigation emphasizes directors' use of visual and narrative instruments in provoking queries about identity, reality, and existence. This involves assessing how story patterns and appearances intertwine to mold, dismantle, or reconstruct characters' identities in both movies.

​

Analyzing "Vagabond" as a Reflection of the Current Social Reality

Depiction of Independence and Estrangement

Agnes Varda's "Vagabond" begins grimly, with the sight of a dead woman abandoned in a ditch. This unsettling image establishes an ominous undertone to the movie, which delves into questions about individuality and one's place within society. The film centers around Mona, who is portrayed as wandering aimlessly through rural France during winter months while confronting societal conventions that she struggles against or intentionally dodges altogether. Throughout her journey, Mona encounters several individuals from various walks of life each embodying their own views on what it means to belong in society alongside harsh norms both challenged and avoided by Mona herself.

The crux of "Vagabond" is Mona's self-determination, as she opts to reside outside the bounds of societal conventions, leading her down a path both isolating and rebellious. The movie presents Mona's autonomy unromantically with an unsparing examination into the difficult realities that accompany such choices; it neither glorifies nor sanitizes the consequences. By demonstrating how much society contributes to Mona’s departure from conventional norms in all aspects – not just personal ones–the interactions hint at broader social alienation themes when examining individualism against conformity more generally. Varda utilizes cinematic realism here effectively to encourage viewers to contemplate whether their concept of ardent freedom aligns with or delimits actuality by reflecting on these outcomes stemming from isolation.

Social commentary combined with cinematic realism.

Varda's film employs a documentary-esque technique that blurs the line between fact and fiction, amplifying its social commentary. By using non-actors in real-life settings, Varda creates an authentic narrative that resonates with viewers on a deeper level as they relate to Mona's experiences. Through this approach, Vardo delves into marginalization more effectively by presenting true-to-life scenarios of those living on society’s periphery.

Using interviews and monologues from different characters in the narrative structure offers diverse viewpoints on Mona's life and actions. This approach amplifies understanding of her character while reflecting societal complexities regarding individuals living on its fringes. By interacting with Mona, each character showcases their biases concerning independence, accountability, and isolation - ultimately contributing to a more profound examination of these themes within the film.

​

Reflecting on the Real-life Challenges of Being Marginalized and Establishing Identity

The message conveyed in "Vagabond" goes beyond a chronicle of an individual wandering alone. It delves into the intricacies of societal regulations and unacknowledged limits imposed on personal liberty. Mona's life highlights the price one has to pay for being ostracized by society, leading them towards acute loneliness while seeking independence in a world that rewards conformity. Varda crafts her narrative through Mona as she critiques social frameworks which restrict marginalized identities from flourishing freely with their own unique traits and attributes.

The movie encourages contemplation on society's treatment of those who defy conventional norms while raising inquiries regarding the mechanisms that either encourage or stifle individualism. These themes showcase the apparent paradox between freedom and structured social systems. With its intricate storytelling approach and genuine depictions, "Vagabond" provides a profound insight into issues like identity crisis, marginalization as well as an inherent human yearning for independence despite societal obstacles.

​

Section 4: "Persona" and the Psychological Realities of Selfhood

​

In "Persona" by Ingmar Bergman, identity is deeply examined as the lines between oneself and others are not only vague but also scrutinized. The story revolves around Elisabet Vogler, an actress who abruptly remains silent while under the care of her nurse Alma. As both characters are secluded from society throughout most of the film, Bergman has a chance to explore intricate matters regarding human beings' psyche and identity in great depth.

As the plot develops, Elisabet and Alma's identities commence to mingle in a psychological interplay that creates ambiguity between personal identity and collective experience. This integration is artistically demonstrated through inventive cinematography such as close-ups capturing even the smallest expressions of their faces, along with mirror shots illustrating reflective distortions of their physical appearance. These techniques deepen the duality theme by highlighting how easily one can shift or merge into another persona while also emphasizing fluidity within individuality boundaries- showcasing how porous they are when it comes to self and others' amalgamation.

​

Psychological depth and visual storytelling

By utilizing techniques such as abrupt cuts, overlays, and symbolic imagery to evoke thought-provoking responses from its audience, Bergman's visual storytelling challenges the limits of traditional narrative structures. These elements are further intensified by the use of stark black-and-white photography that creates an aesthetically bold yet psychologically penetrating atmosphere.

The merging of Elisabet and Alma's faces in a famous shot is a visual representation of the film's exploration of identity, challenging not only viewers' perception of characters but also their understanding that selfhood is fixed. Through Bergman's use of silence as a narrative tool, the psychological depth intensifies when Elisabet refuses to speak - shifting audiences' focus from words spoken towards non-verbal communication as a key elements for comprehending oneself and others.

​

Encounters with self-identity and interpersonal connections

By depicting the dynamic evolution of Elisabet and Alma's relationship, "Persona" prompts its audience to confront the intricate nature of their own identities and connections with others. The movie implies that identity is not solely a product of individual perception but intricately intertwined with our relational experiences. Unearthing concealed desires, anxieties, and vulnerabilities through interactions between these two female characters unearth universal emotions inherent in human beings.

Bergman delves into the concept of identity through individual psychology and also scrutinizes how societal expectations and cultural norms sculpt personal identification. The film concentrates intensely on two women, symbolizing a small part of broader inquiries concerning gender roles, social identity's performative facets, as well as existential loneliness that may accompany self-discovery pursuits.

 

Section 5: Implications in Real Life and Comparative Analysis

​

Participating in philosophical concepts

Although both "Vagabond" and "Persona" delve deeply into topics of self-awareness, personal identity, and the complexities of being human; their distinctive narrative approaches and cinematic techniques reflect unique philosophical explorations.

The quasi-documentary style employed by “Vagabond” directs attention to the outskirts of society and Mona's life is presented in fragmented episodes, urging viewers to reappraise societal norms related to liberty and disaffection. Agnes Varda underscores the existential truth concerning personal choices and their corresponding repercussion on social structures with her methodology.

Utilizing psychological and symbolic narratives, “Persona” delves into the flexible nature of personal identity and the mutual reliance between personas in intimate connections. Through Ingmar Bergman's implementation of visual duplication and reflective imagery, not only is one prompted to contemplate their self-defined stability within this context but also how interpersonal relations factor into constructing our sense of selves.

​

Real-life experiences that resonate

Viewers are prompted to contemplate their perceptions of identity and societal roles in both films. "Vagabond" depicts the brutal truths associated with forging a life beyond social conventions, tackling existential concepts such as independence and loneliness that align with Egan's remark: "Social norms mold individuals' identities in everyday Dasein rather than isolation." (Egan, p. 6). This statement highlights the movie's condemnation of societal frameworks that confine or restrict an individual’s sense of self-identity.

"Persona" challenges conventional views on character identification and offers a more introspective examination of identity. It suggests that our sense of self is not fixed but rather, fluid and interconnected. The film's narrative techniques align with Smith's perspective on the role of narration in shaping one's identity as it generates recognition, alignment, and allegiance through sympathy structure (Smith p 35). Moreover, Smith notes how everyday conversations often present an oversimplified monolithic conception of identification where viewers are expected to feel empathy for just one protagonist (Smith p.36), something which "Persona"'s visual strategies circumvent by presenting two characters who blur their respective identities into each other thereby deepening Bergman’s challenge to traditional notions around cinematic character identification models.

​

Using Cinematic Art as a Means to Comprehend Self-Identity

By utilizing their unique cinematic languages, the movies aim to enrich viewers' comprehension of individual identity and broaden their perspectives of actuality. Varda and Bergman employ self-exploration as a means for conveying an innovative film philosophy that resonates with Wittgenstein's "All explanation must disappear, and description alone must take its place" (Egan 1). Through films like "Vagabond" and "Persona," they invite audiences into existential queries through visual depictions rather than straightforward clarifications.

​

Section 6: Using Cinematic Exploration of Selfhood to Bridge the Gap Between Art and Reality

Synthesis of Contributions from Philosophy and Cinema

The films "Vagabond" and "Persona" serve as prime examples of how cinema can transcend mere entertainment by engaging deeply with profound philosophical inquiries about the human experience. Far beyond simply portraying characters and their stories, these works challenge viewers to reconsider existential issues such as identity, autonomy, and the nature of reality through innovative cinematic techniques that provoke deep contemplation.

Agnes Varda and Ingmar Bergman utilize their films as tools for exploring philosophical ideas, integrating form and content to challenge the nature of self-identity. Through distinctive storytelling techniques and visual aesthetics, these films encourage viewers to experience intricate concepts on a deeper level. This immersion reinforces Wittgenstein's claim that when facing profound existential or philosophical inquiries "description alone must take its place" (Egan, p.1). Consequently, both filmmakers rely more heavily on powerful depictions than explicit explanations in conveying their philosophies throughout each film's narrative arc.

​

The Cinematic Techniques' Capacity for Transformation

The utilization of cinematic techniques in both films highlights the ability of film to connect artistic expression with authentic life experiences. Through its direct camera addresses, naturalistic sound effects, and episodic narrative structure, "Vagabond" immerses viewers into Mona's world forcing them to grapple with societal biases as well as the challenging realities that accompany deviating from established norms. On a similar note, "Persona" employs visual mirroring, sharp editing, and symbolic imagery which obfuscate distinctions between oneself and others; this leads people watching to ponder over their identities' fluidity while keeping tabs on socially constructed conventions.

By utilizing such techniques, the narrative is not only enriched but also stimulates a more profound interaction with the film's themes. This facilitates introspection beyond its runtime and highlights how cinema can impact and reshape perspectives by connecting personal experiences with universal existential concepts. The movie evoking self-reflection demonstrates the potency of storytelling in influencing perceptions effectively.

​

Implications of Self-Knowledge for Perceiving Reality

The films "Vagabond" and "Persona", examined through the medium of cinema, expand our comprehension of how people maneuver their personal identities in an intricate world. Through cinematic means, these works provide insight into weighty philosophical discussions around identity and existence that can be applied to everyday life. The films inspire introspection about how societal expectations, intimate connections with others, and internal dilemmas influence an individual's conception of selfhood.

These films do not offer conclusive explanations of self-identity, but they initiate a discourse between the spectator and the motion picture that promotes an uninterrupted pursuit of introspection. This lively interplay highlights art's contribution in not only illustrating actuality but also modifying and testing our interpretations of it.

​

Section 7: Summing Up

​

The complexity in which "Vagabond" by Agnès Varda and "Persona" by Ingmar Bergman examine the philosophical landscape of selfhood has been examined thoroughly in this paper, effectively merging cinematic art with real-life implications. These two films surpass simple storytelling; they actively encourage audience members to engage in a profound dialogue regarding the essence of identity, existence, and self-discovery.

"Vagabond" offers a blunt representation of independence and isolation, encouraging audience members to ponder social conventions and their impact on personal selfhood. By painting an authentic picture of marginalization, Varda urges us to reevaluate our perceptions and biases towards those who are excluded from mainstream society. The film pushes us to examine how we view the marginalized community as well as question societal norms that lead individuals down paths toward alienation.

Bergman's "Persona" explores the intricate aspects of identity and duality using avant-garde film techniques. By daring viewers to delve into their own psyches, Bergman exposes how personal relationships shape an individual's self-image. This intense experimental movie pushes cinematic boundaries by prompting profound introspection in audiences; challenging conventional understanding of psychological exploration through cinema.

Through a comparative analysis of these films, it becomes evident that the authenticity of selfhood serves as a common thematic thread. The directors employ filmmaking not solely for philosophical representation but also to incite active engagement with their themes, provoking viewers' introspective contemplation of their personal lives and identities. These cinematic works induce scrutiny of one's own sense of identity through discerning insights into the human experience and perception.

Additionally, this research highlights how film serves as a potent tool to delve into philosophical inquiries and real-world contemplation. Grasping intricate theoretical queries through captivating storylines makes for an exceptional way of scrutinizing and comprehending the intricacies of identity, memory, and being. The impact of such examinations is not confined only to filmmaking but permeates other domains like psychology, sociology, or philosophy thus enhancing our perception of human existence.

Exploring the intersection of film, philosophy, and cinematic explorations of selfhood has promising future research prospects. Delving deeper into how movies like "Vagabond" and "Persona" expand our realm of understanding about the world can offer insights into who we are as individuals and why we hold significance in society. This paper establishes that cinema not only mirrors reality but also holds transformative potential to shape it by offering novel perspectives on age-old inquiries into human identity.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Bibliography

Baron, Cynthia. “The self and the other in Roeg’s Eureka and Sartre’s being and Nothingness.” Film and Philosophy, vol. 2, 1995, pp. 45–57, https://doi.org/10.5840/filmphil199524.

Bergman, Ingmar, director. Persona. Svensk Filmindustri, 1966.

Gallagher, Shaun. Phenomenology. Palgrave Macmillan, 2012.

Litch, Mary. Philosophy through Film. Routledge, 2002.

Livingston, Paisley. Cinema, Philosophy, Bergman: On Film as Philosophy. Oxford University Press, 2012.

Luft, Sebastian, and Søren Overgaard. The Routledge Companion to Phenomenology. Routledge, 2014.

Mulhall, Stephen. “Picturing the human (body and soul).” Film and Philosophy, vol. 1, 1994, pp. 87–104, https://doi.org/10.5840/filmphil1994111.

Smith, Joel Alexander. Existentialism: A Philosophical Inquiry. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2022.

Varda, Agnes, director. Vagabond. 1985.

Zahavi, Dan. Phenomenology: The Basics. Routledge, 2019.

Egan, David. “Authenticity and the Everyday.” The Pursuit of an Authentic Philosophy, 20 Mar. 2019, pp. 110–137, https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198832638.003.0005.

Smith, Murray. “Altered states: Character and emotional response in the cinema.” Cinema Journal, vol. 33, no. 4, 1994, p. 34, https://doi.org/10.2307/1225898.